I admit that from the time it was announced at E3 until the present, I was less than enthused at the prospect of having my old interface, which I personally loved, replaced by the typical Vista-esque interface that Microsoft has been attempted to push on us for the last few years. Nevertheless I kept an open mind going into it, and I have to admit it isn't all bad.
When you first log in, you wait for about 5min for the update to download and install, and when it finishes you are faced with a character

Compared to the Wii's Miis or w/e they're called (I haven't tried the PS3 avatar thing, so I won't comment on it), it is vastly superior. However, as I hinted at above, I strongly recommend NOT making a character that looks like yourself. There is a strong chance he'll come out odd, gay, or even retarded looking, so try and go for a look more original look, lest you be another generic avatar no one takes a second glance at.
Once you have completed creating your avatar, you'll find yourself staring breathlessly at the vast new expanses of the NXE, taking in the wonderful new features such as _________, and ______ ___________. Seriously though, the NXE doesn't really add a whole lot of features to the previous interface. The only significant feature of this update, besides avatars and a new interface, is the ability to make groups, which allows for party gaming and voice chat with multiple people at the same time, features that should have been added years ago. I'm not particualarily surprised however, as it is more or less what I expected, and Microsoft didn't exactly claim that they were going to add anything more, it's just that they brand it as a 'New Experience' when all it was is a new skin to an old interface.
A good way Microsoft could have promoted this would have been by adding a few free 'avatar games', playable by anyone with the new interface. These could have just been simple things such as bumper cars or musical chairs. They would have been immediatly popular, and would have expanded the whole avatar promotion, however no such system exists. There are games which include, however it is limited to only a few, which you have to pay for, and consist of your avatar standing there, presumably doing silly little animations occasionally as to not look like a boring sack of bricks. Avatar games would have most likely increased my attention span of the new interface from just under an hour to at least over 3.
However pessimistic I may seem, the interface, for the most part, is an improvement over the previous one. Marketplace has a MUCH better layout now, and the friends menu, however spread out and annoying, allows you to see each of your friend's avatars in either their own private space, or the party which they happen to be in along with the rest of the party members.


One major concern with the NXE is that gamer pictures and themes would become void with the new system, but need not worry, as gamer pictures have not changed at all, and themes get a neat new look.

Overall the 'New Xbox Experience' is an improvement over the old interface. Although it is not really needed, it brings a fresh look to the system and should be welcomed by all gamers. Although it lacks new features, only adding what should have been with the original interface, and even suffers from a few bugs, it makes up for it in appearance and accessibility. If you own an Xbox, I recommend jumping on for an hour and playing with it, and you may even have a little bit of fun.